top of page

When Behaviour Is Mistaken for Character

Nov 4
3 min read

Elizabeth Mateer’s Psychology Today article “When Exhaustion Becomes a Character Flaw” names a problem that reaches far beyond sleep disorders. She writes about narcolepsy and the way invisible symptoms can be mistaken for laziness, disengagement, or lack of discipline. The deeper issue is not only exhaustion. It is the moral story people attach to exhaustion, or any behaviour, when they don't understand what they are seeing.


That distinction is important for actors because actors study behaviour. But we can easily make the same mistake Mateer describes. We see behaviour and rush to "character choices" when we should be looking one or two levels beneath what we see.


He is lazy.

She is weak.

They are manipulative.

That person is a tyrant.


This shortcut feels efficient, but it gives the actor a verdict instead of a field of possibility.

In Crosspoints, this is one of the reasons the emblems and archetypal partners have to remain morally neutral.


The emblems are behavioural patterns. They name how a person may be organizing themselves in a scene. It presents offers and prompts about how they pursue a goal, yield, resist, control, conceal, or perceive the world around them. They are not diagnoses and when using them, the actor should avoid pathologizing what's happening. They are invitations to investigate a behaviour.

The archetypal partners describe relational positions. They ask: who does the other person seem, to me, in this moment? A judge, rebel, martyr, child, tyrant, saviour? Again, these are not fixed identities. And they aren't always what the person actually is, or how they see themselves. They are ways of naming the way you see a relationship, now.


This is important because labels carry morality, but we have to step back from judgement.

Take an emblem like the Puppet.


At first, if you take on puppet behaviour, it sounds diminished. It suggests servitude, dependency, manipulation, or a loss of agency. But that is only one possible reading. A puppet may be bound to a duty, yes. A puppet may have surrendered. But a person who gives themselves over to service is not automatically weak. It can also describe devotion, discipline, public service, spiritual surrender, apprenticeship, care work, or a life organized around helping.


The actor cannot assume the moral meaning too early.


The better question is: where is the agency being transferred? Where is the sense of purpose giving the puppet internal comfort and a sense of reward?


Are they serving something larger than themselves?

Do they know the strings are there?


That line of questioning gives the actor choices that judging the character does not.


The same applies to the archetypal partner tyrant.


Remember that the partner refers to how you core the other person.


Tyrant carries obvious negative force. It suggests cruelty, illegitimate power, oppression, or domination. Historically, though, the term is more complicated. In ancient Greece, a tyrant could refer to a ruler who held power outside ordinary constitutional inheritance or legal right; like a revolutionary. The word did not always carry only the modern sense of cruelty, though it did develop strong negative associations, especially in modern political thought. Tyrants in days of old often gained popular support by challenging aristocratic privilege.


So, in Crosspoints, a tyrant is not simply “a bad, doninrering person.”


A tyrant is someone who holds an imbalanced amount of power in relation to another. That power may be institutional, emotional, financial, sexual, intellectual, parental, charismatic, spiritual, etc..


The tyrant may still be cruel. But the card should not begin with cruelty. It should begin just with imbalance.


Who has power?

Who gave it to them?

Who fears its redistribution?

What does it distort?


These questions take the actor out of their person psychology and into their construction of the world. This is the best sort of dramatic investigation for a large role.


Moralizing behaviour can be a shortcut. But we need moral judgment in life. Harm is real. Abuse is real. Responsibility and accountability matter. But in rehearsal, premature judgment can disguise the behaviour we are trying to understand. It takes away choice. 


Mateer’s article shows how damaging this can be in ordinary life. Symptoms become flaws. A body trying to survive becomes an indictment of character. Behaviour is the surface where the person starts to become visible, but it is not the whole person.


For me, this is one of the ethical strengths of actor training when it is done well. It teaches us to look harder before we decide. It teaches us that beong someone has contexts, and costs. It teaches us to avoid simplification.


We are allowed to say an action causes harm without reducing the person to a simplified moral label or a cartoon villain.


We can say someone submits without assuming they lack dignity.

Once we apply these labels, we stop seeing.


But when behaviour provokes questions, the real scene begins.


Comments


bottom of page